Note: This post now archived and as such no longer works
This is possible because Lemmy doesn’t proxy external images but instead loads them directly. While not all that bad, this could be used for Spy pixels by nefarious posters and commenters.
Note, that the only thing that I willingly log is the “hit count” visible in the image, and I have no intention to misuse the data.
I guess it knows that it’s unknown
I guess mobile clients screw with their fingerprinting method. Also doesn’t work on Slide.
Wait what, slideforreddit works for lemmy now?
looks like sync in the screenshot, i think thats what they meant
It sees my phone fine (Chrome on Android)
It’s the same for me
I guess Donald Rumsfeld was right.
This is true for most link aggregators that attempt to render external content. Proxying images and videos would dramatically increase costs.
If you care that much about anonymity, use a VPN/Tor and a browser with advanced fingerprinting resistance — tor browser, mullvad browser, or firefox with resist fingerprinting = true.
deleted by creator
That makes sense. But I guess there’s these questions: at what resolution? For how long? Maybe the status quo is such because it’s simpler code. The project is still relatively young. I wonder where/how we can discuss these things?
deleted by creator
It still adds up fast especially if you run an instance that stores to s3 with a cdn. My mastodon server racked up 1k in cdn usage one month before I switched to local storage no cdn.
At the very least setting referer policy headers and such would be a good addition.
That’s great except those browsers often don’t work.
Hexbear.net stays winning, external embeds are domain whitelist-only until pictrs adds proxying support, and blurred by default.
Good PSA tho, I’d honestly encourage other instances to do the same but it requires dev effort that I know not everyone has, and upstream isn’t quite as paranoid about this stuff.
For reference:
Cool, didn’t know some Lemmy instances did this
Is there a pull request for it though?
as far as I know upstream lemmy doesn’t want it and is waiting on pictrs proxying support. If I’m wrong though our code is public, I’m sure a dev would be happy to put together a PR,
*removed externally hosted image*
Looks like your home instance hexbear.net is filtering external images.
This reminds me of those old forum signatures which looked like a signpost, and showed your IP address, browser, OS etc. They were pretty popular back then (when no one cared about their privacy), to the point that some folks even made parody versions of those signatures (like changing the IP to “127.0.0.1” or writing a funny message).
My favorite Linux distro: Windows.
This ain’t me!
But I’m not on chrome mobile…
*brave
